It's always a kind gesture to congratulate someone on their birthday, regardless of whether they have done the same for you in the past. By acknowledging their special day, you are showing that you care about them and are thinking of them. It's important to be gracious and extend well wishes, even if the same courtesy has not been extended to you. Ultimately, it's about spreading positivity and kindness, regardless of the actions of others. **

Nobody congratulates the person who gives up easily and does not put in the effort to achieve their goals. Success and achievements are usually celebrated when they are the result of hard work, determination, and perseverance. Those who do not show dedication or commitment to their goals often do not receive congratulations from others. **

Yes, Ex did congratulate afterwards. After the event or achievement, Ex reached out to offer their congratulations and express their support. This gesture showed that Ex was able to put aside any past differences and genuinely celebrate the success of the other person. **

Yes, it is still appropriate to congratulate someone on their birthday even if they did not congratulate you on yours. Birthdays are a time to celebrate and show kindness, regardless of whether the other person remembered your birthday. It's a chance to extend well wishes and show that you care about the person, regardless of their actions. It's always a good opportunity to be the bigger person and spread positivity. **

It is always a kind gesture to wish someone a happy birthday, regardless of whether they have wished you a happy birthday in the past. By congratulating them, you are showing that you care about them and are thinking of them on their special day. It is a way to maintain positive relationships and show kindness, even if the gesture is not reciprocated. **

Yes, I would still congratulate my friend on their birthday even if they didn't congratulate me. Birthdays are a special occasion and it's important to show love and support for our friends, regardless of whether they remembered our birthday or not. It's a chance to celebrate their life and show them that they are important to us. I believe in spreading positivity and kindness, so I would definitely still extend my well wishes to my friend. **

Nobody congratulates themselves. Typically, congratulations are given by others to acknowledge and celebrate someone's achievements or milestones. Self-congratulation is seen as self-praise or self-admiration, which may come across as boastful or arrogant. Instead, it is more common for individuals to receive congratulations from friends, family, colleagues, or acquaintances. **

There could be several reasons why she didn't congratulate you. It's possible that she may not have been aware of the achievement or forgot to acknowledge it. She could also be dealing with personal issues or distractions that prevented her from congratulating you. It's important to communicate with her directly to understand her perspective and address any misunderstandings. **